Best Italian Restaurants in Cookislands

Charlie's Raro has earned its stellar reputation as one of the Cook Islands' most beloved watering holes, where locals and travelers mix effortlessly in a laid-back island atmosphere that perfectly captures the spirit of Rarotonga. With over 800 glowing reviews, visitors consistently praise the friendly service, cold drinks, and authentic local vibe that makes this spot feel like a true island institution. Arrive in the early evening to snag a good spot and soak up the sunset while mingling with both fellow travelers and welcoming locals who make this place so special.

Tamarind House combines tropical dining with live ukulele entertainment, creating an authentic Cook Islands atmosphere that keeps both locals and visitors coming back. With an impressive 4.6-star rating from hundreds of reviews, guests consistently praise the laid-back island vibe and welcoming service that makes everyone feel like family. Arrive early to snag a good seat for the evening's musical performances, when the restaurant truly comes alive with traditional island sounds.

Nestled in the heart of Aitutaki, Avatea cafe has earned an impressive 4.9-star rating from over 300 visitors who rave about its welcoming island atmosphere and consistently excellent food and service. This beloved local spot perfectly captures the laid-back Cook Islands vibe while delivering quality cafe fare that keeps both tourists and locals coming back. Arrive early to snag the best seats and soak in the authentic island charm that makes this cafe a standout dining experience.

This highly-rated beachfront resort restaurant offers stunning lagoon views and a relaxed tropical atmosphere that keeps guests and visitors coming back for more. With an impressive 4.9-star rating from over 300 reviews, diners consistently praise both the scenic setting and quality dining experience. Book a table during sunset hours to make the most of the spectacular oceanfront location while enjoying drinks and island-inspired cuisine.

The Waterline Restaurant and Outrigger Beach Bar combines oceanfront dining with a laid-back tropical atmosphere that perfectly captures the essence of Rarotonga's coastal charm. With nearly 300 glowing reviews and a stellar 4.5-star rating, travelers consistently praise this spot for its diverse menu options and beachside setting that makes every meal feel like a vacation highlight. Arrive early for sunset dining to snag the best waterfront tables and soak in those legendary Cook Islands views.

Perched on stunning Muri Beach, Nautilus Restaurant offers diverse international cuisine with breathtaking lagoon views that create an unforgettable dining atmosphere. With an exceptional 4.9-star rating from nearly 200 reviews, travelers consistently rave about both the food quality and the spectacular beachfront setting. Book ahead for sunset dining to secure the best tables overlooking the turquoise waters, as this popular spot fills up quickly during peak evening hours.

This beloved beachside spot in Arorangi has earned a stellar reputation among travelers for its diverse menu and laid-back island atmosphere, with nearly 200 glowing reviews praising both the food quality and friendly service. The varied cuisine options mean there's something for everyone, from fresh local dishes to international favorites, all served in a relaxed tropical setting. Book ahead or arrive early, as this popular gem tends to fill up quickly with both locals and visitors in the know.