Best Italian Restaurants in Cook Islands

$$

Charlie's Raro has earned its stellar reputation as one of the Cook Islands' most beloved watering holes, where locals and travelers mingle in a laid-back atmosphere that perfectly captures the island spirit. With over 800 glowing reviews, visitors consistently praise the friendly service, cold drinks, and authentic island vibe that makes this bar a must-visit social hub. Arrive in the early evening to snag a good spot and soak up the sunset while experiencing why this place has become a Rarotonga institution.

Ara Tapu, Takitumu District, Cook Islands

View Map Website

$$

This vibrant beachside spot in Avarua perfectly combines tropical cocktails with live ukulele entertainment, creating an authentic Cook Islands atmosphere that keeps both locals and tourists coming back. With an impressive 4.6-star rating from nearly 500 reviews, guests consistently praise the laid-back vibe and friendly service that makes everyone feel welcome. Arrive early evening to snag a good seat for the live music while enjoying sunset drinks at this popular gathering spot.

Ara Tapu, Avarua, Cook Islands

View Map

$$

This beloved cafe on Aitutaki has earned an impressive 4.9-star rating from over 330 reviews, making it a standout dining spot that consistently delivers exceptional food and service in a relaxed island atmosphere. Travelers rave about the quality and authenticity of the cafe experience, with the high review count proving it's a local favorite that visitors discover and love. Arrive early to secure the best seating and soak in the genuine Cook Islands cafe culture that keeps guests coming back.

Tautu Aitutaki Aitutaki, Cook Islands

View Map Website

$$

Pacific Resort Aitutaki delivers an exceptional island dining experience that has earned rave reviews from over 300 visitors, combining stunning beachfront atmosphere with quality cuisine and drinks. The resort's restaurant consistently impresses travelers with its relaxed tropical setting and attentive service, making it a standout choice on this pristine Cook Islands atoll. Book ahead during peak season as this highly-rated spot fills up quickly, and consider timing your visit for sunset to make the most of the spectacular lagoon views.

Pacific Resort Aitutaki Main Road Amuri, Aitutaki, Cook Islands

View Map Website

$$

The Waterline Restaurant and Outrigger Beach Bar offers a perfect beachfront dining experience in Arorangi, combining stunning oceanfront views with diverse international cuisine that keeps both locals and visitors coming back. With an impressive 4.5-star rating from nearly 300 reviews, travelers consistently praise the relaxed island atmosphere and quality food at reasonable prices. Arrive early for sunset dining to snag the best waterfront tables and soak in the spectacular Rarotonga coastline views.

Q5CC+Q8F Arorangi, Rarotonga, Cook Islands

View Map Website

$$

Perched along stunning Muri Beach, Nautilus Restaurant has earned an impressive 4.9-star rating from nearly 200 diners who rave about its diverse menu and breathtaking oceanfront setting. The combination of various international cuisines and prime beachside location creates an unforgettable dining experience that keeps both locals and tourists coming back. Book ahead for sunset dining to secure the best tables overlooking the lagoon, as this popular spot fills up quickly during peak hours.

Muri Beach, Rarotonga, Cook Islands

View Map Website

$$

Kikau Hut on Ara Tapu offers a delightful dining experience with its varied international menu that has earned rave reviews from nearly 200 visitors who consistently praise its quality and atmosphere. This mid-range gem clearly delivers exceptional value, as evidenced by its impressive 4.7-star rating that speaks to both locals and travelers finding something special here. Book ahead or arrive early, as popular spots like this in the Cook Islands can fill up quickly, especially during peak dining hours.

Ara Tapu, Arorangi, Cook Islands

View Map Website